WHRnet - Women's Human Rights Net - Providing comprehensive information and analysis on women's human rights and global issues
WHRnet Home | Challenging Fundamentalisms | UN Conferences | Treaty Bodies & Instruments | HR Systems
Archive | Links | Search WHRnet | About WHRnet | Your Feedback | Subscribe | Español | Français
Emerging Issues from the NGO Beijing + 10 Review
December 2004
Presentation by Charlotte Bunch, Center for Women's Global Leadership, Chair of the NGO Working Group on Emerging Issues

UNECE Regional Preparatory Meeting - Europe & North America on the 10-Year Review of the Beijing Platform for Action

The Emerging Issues Working Group, like all of the NGO Working Groups, reaffirms the continuing relevance of the Beijing Platform for Action and of the Outcome Document from the Beijing + 5 Review, and stresses the urgency of accelerated action toward its implementation. Women of the world see the Beijing Platform as a vital social compact between governments and citizens pledging to work together toward the fulfillment of the human rights of all women. Women in all regions are watching this 10-Year Review of the Beijing Platform for Action to ensure that this remains a solid commitment and not a string of broken promises. And, we know a lot of broken promises.

I speak today about the conclusions from the NGO Emerging Issues Workshop, which looked at critical areas not adequately covered in the Platform, and at trends affecting its implementation. When I spoke here five years ago at the Plus Five ECE Review, NGO's were more optimistic about the future of progress on the human rights of women than we are today.

The overarching concern of NGO's is the way in which global forces that have intensified over the decade, have often eroded support for, and attention to, women's human rights. In particular, we want to stress that the increase in militarism and armed conflicts, the growth of fundamentalisms of many kinds, and the growing inequities produced by global economic policies are major obstacles detrimental to the achievement of the Beijing Platform for Action.

We begin by stating emphatically that we reject all excuses for violations of women's human rights whether in the name of "national security" or of "cultual heritage," or religion. The global "war on terrorism" should not be used as an excuse to undermine any group's human rights or to actively neglect the critical issues of women's daily human insecurities caused by poverty, violence against women, etc. The politics of greed, exclusion, domination, and military power have failed women in the ECE Region. We affirm multilateralism as the way to address global security concerns, and we call upon governments to develop better alternaives for our collective human security based in respect for all human rights.

The group identified many specific critical areas of emerging concern. I will speak to the major topical areas; and my colleague, Beata will speak about the specific issues of diverse women's constituencies discussed by the group.

1. Militarism - Women Peace, & Security:

Given the current geopolitical context of war, heightened military spending, the promotion of a culture of violence in daily life, and the increased transnational crime and corruption, we recommend:

  • National governments should counter this climate of violence related to "the war on terror" by more actively promoting peace, disarmament, and intercultural dialogue. Military budgets must be reduced, and defense spending shifted to poverty reduction, development, and the protection of human rights.
  • Implement Security Council Resolution 1325 through an action plan, an audit of existing funds, and the appointment of a Special Rapporteur on Security Council Resolution 1325.
  • UN Peace Keeping Forces: Include more women in decision making positions; develop gender monitoring mechansims an trainings on local contexts; and end impunity for violence perpetrated by peacekeepers.
  • International Organizations with a mandate to work on organized crime need to review their activities, increase transparency, disclose full budgets, and increase public space for discussion of their work and mandates.

2. Fundamentalisms: We oppose all forms of fundamentalisms because they create and demonize "the Other" and use religion, cultural heritage, nationalism, and ethnicity to obtain political power to control women's lives. Governments must ensure that civic rights laws are implemented and enforced. The principle of secularity should be represented by each State in all its policies.

3. Sexual Rights: Sexual rights embrace human rights already recognized in national laws, international and regional human rights and consensus documents.

  • All women, including young women, have the right to make informed choices about their sexual and reproductive lives, including sexual autonomy, sexual orientation, and sexual pleasure, and must have access to comprehensive sex education, and confidential sexual and reproductive services, including safe and legal abortion, male and female condoms.
  • All women must have freedom to establish all forms of families and to exercise sexual rights free from gender-based violence and coercion, including FGM, forced and early marriage, so-called honor killings, and domestic violence.
  • Governments must create enabling conditions to ensure enjoyment of sexual rights.
  • The UN Secretary General's in-depth study on all forms of violence against women for the General Assembly should include consideration of how gender-based violence violates women's sexual rights.

4. HIV/AIDS: As over 50% of people infected with HIV are now women, women's experience and gender equality must be central to discussion of all aspects of HIV/AIDS - access to treatment, the links between violence against women and HIV, epidemiology of the pandemic. etc.

  • Prevention and treatment programs must be designed within a human rights framework and with community participation. HIV/AIDS strategies must encompass sexual and reproductive health rights with special attention to young women, through the promotion of comprehensive sexuality education.
  • Female controlled prevention methods such as microbicides and female condoms must be accessible and affordable, and women must be involved in the design and delivery of antiretroviral (ARV) programs.

5. Information & Communications Technology: ICT's offer possibilities for achieving women's rights and gender equality, eliminating poverty, overcoming women's isolation, and improving governance.

  • Governments must: provide education on effectively and safely using and shaping ICT's and ensure all ICT initiatives, policies, and programs incorporate a gender perspective.
  • We must make governments accountable for benchmarking and reaching goals regarding policies and investments that ensure that women of all ages have affordable access and can generate, own, develop, and use and adapt ICT's and content.
  • There is a need to create a synergy between old and new ICT's to overcome digital divides within and between societies, including between genders.
  • Policies and regulatory frameworks are needed to address violent and exploitative images, but we should ensure these are not used to enforce censorship and surveillance, or to limit access to information or invade privacy.

6. Public Services: We are concerned at the trend in the region toward deregulation, privatisation, and cuts in public services previously provided largely by the state and that adversely affect women.

  • The State has a duty to provide water, sanitation, primary health care, education, and care services for children and other dependent people. We oppose the shift of costs and workload caused by privatization and cuts in funding from the State to households, which often creates particular hardship for women.
  • Public services must be seen as an instrument of social cohesion, public good and gender equality; the State must remain answerable for the quality of public services and equal access for all. Any change of public service provision by the State should be subject to a gender impact assessment.

Finally, the group expressed concern about two other topics not developed in depth:

7. Biotechnology/ New Technologies: We must ensure gender and women's participation in all aspects of developing new technologies.

8. Women & The Environment: We take note of the escalating degradation of the earth and the urgency of involving women in decision making on the full range of environmental issues.

IN CLOSING, this is an urgent moment for the advancement of the human rights of women around the world, and we count on you to not only affirm the Beijing Platform for Action here today and to take concrete steps and commit resources to its implementation, but also to address the challenges that have arisen since Beijing that impinge upon women's rights.

In short, we call on you to show the women of the world whose eyes are on you today, that the promises made to them over the past 30 years since IWY in Mexico City, are not empty, and that together we will continue to advance in the pursuit of human rights for all women everywhere.


Section II

The Beijing Platform for Action and the Outcomes Document from the Beijing + 5 Review, both have paragraphs in which the diversity of women's experiences and the differential impact of issues on different groups of women, is acknowledged. We affirm the need to look at such diversity in seeking to implement the Beijing Platform and call upon governments to affirm the human rights of all women, regardless of whether they are named in such lists. The Emerging Issues Working Group affirms the need for attention to all marginalized or oppressed groups of women and has chosen to look in particular at 7 such constituencies in the ECE Region - some of whom are not acknowledged in previous documents and all of whose lives have not been sufficiently addressed. We also note that while these groups are often victimized in ways that require particular attention, they are not only victims, but also can be agents whose knowledge and perspectives prove vital to creating new solutions and approaches to issues.

1. Youth
Young people have the right to participate in the design, decision making, implementation, and evaluation of policies and programs in all sectors, not just those identified as being specifically related to youth, and to be compensated appropriately by NGO's and governments for their time and effort. When young people do participate, they must compose a critical mass of at least 20% so as not to further tokenize their involvement.

2. Romany Women
In most of the CEE/CIS countries, Romany women and girls are denied civil, political, economic, social, and cultural rights. As a result, Romany women and girls live in extreme poverty and face social exclusion and multiple forms of discrimination. We demand State parties mainstream Romany women and girls issues throughout the national strategies on Roman communities, and strategies on equality between women and men. Therefore, we demand State parties to allocate specific financial resources for effective implementation of these strategies.

3. Indigenous Women
As reflected in the United Nations Draft Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, Indigenous Peoples are "equal in dignity and rights to all other peoples, while recognizing the right of all peoples to be different, to consider themselves different, and to be respected as such."

In keeping with the Beijing Platform for Action, Indigenous Women's issues must be reaffirmed and included in all discussions and recommendations put foward in all aspects of implementation of the Beijing Platform for Action, and in other emerging areas.

4. Lesbians & Bisexual Women
All lesbian, bisexual transgender, and intersex people who identify as women or girls, are entitled to the full enjoyment of all civil, political, economic, social, and cultural rights

5. Women with Disabilities
Recognizing that women with disabilities are subject to multiple forms of discrimination, efforts should be undertaken in order to include an article on the extremely difficult situations of these women into the "draft comprehensive and integral international convention on the protection and promotion of the rights and dignity of persons with disabilities."

6. Older Women
Population aging is a gender issue. Older women outnumber older men across the whole Region and particularly in Central and Eastern Europe. Well being in later life is directly related to experiences across the life course. Therefore, the greater disadvantages women face throughout their lives can lead to living their later years in poverty, isolation, and poor health.

7. Widows
Dur to armed conflict, ethnic cleansing, HIV/AIDS, and the reduced life expectancy of men, particularly in Eastern Europe, the numbers of widows of all ages have risen at unprecedented rates. Changes in political and economic systems in Eastern European countries have negatively impacted widows, their dependents, and society at large. Poverty and marginalization of widows requires urgent attention, as their situations can expose them and their children increasingly to violence in all foms, including economic and sexual exploitation. Governments and the international community must address the issues of widows, collect statistics on widows' experience, provide benefits and services where needed, and support widow-related public policy in the ECE Region.

WHRnet Home | Challenging Fundamentalisms | UN Conferences | Treaty Bodies & Instruments | HR Systems
Archive | Links | Search WHRnet | About WHRnet | Your Feedback | Subscribe | Español | Français
Please visit the Association for Women's Rights in Development WHRnet